News of truck company closures continues to stress a freight industry still struggling to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. It would seem no trucking company is too big to fail in the current economy, with not even giants such as Yellow Corporation spared.
With nearly 73% of the nation’s freight moved by trucks, businesses that rely on trucks for freight handling have expressed concern.
Trucks deliver essential goods to every corner of the U.S., driving commerce and supporting industries from manufacturing to retail. Yet, despite its crucial role, a significant number of trucking companies have shut down operations. This phenomenon raises pressing questions for both trucking companies and the businesses that depend on them.
Understanding the complex reasons behind this decline is essential for stakeholders in the industry and for the broader economic ecosystem that relies on the seamless flow of goods.
Truck Company Closures by the Number
At least 88,000 truck carriers and 8,000 freight brokers made the difficult decision to close operations in 2023, according to data analyzed by CarrierOK. A 30% decrease in freight volume contributed to the closures.
Among the most notable truck company closures included Yellow Corporation and Convoy, two of the biggest names in the business. Other trucking companies that shut down in 2023 include:
- Matheson Trucking announced plans to wind down its operations in December 2023 after prolonged financial disputes.
- Surge Transportation filed for bankruptcy in July 2023 after significant operational changes and ongoing financial struggles.
- Transplus filed for bankruptcy in June 2023, leaving numerous small trucking companies unpaid for their services.
Among the trucking companies that have closed in 2024:
- Arnold Transportation Services, a 92-year-old company based in Grand Prairie, Texas, filed for bankruptcy in May.
- Flagship Transport, a Miami-Dade trucking company, closed its operations in May, leaving over 200 employees without work.
Economic Pressures Squeeze Trucking Company Finances
American political consultant James Carville coined the term, “It’s the economy, stupid,” in 1992 while the U.S. was embroiled in a recession. His quip has gone on to live in infamy, forever applied to situations in which the economy plays a vital role. The bankruptcy and closure of truck companies in the U.S. are among them.
Fluctuating diesel fuel prices have made budgeting a challenge for trucking companies. “Fuel price volatility can wreck a budget,” said Jeffrey Zhou, CEO and founder of Fig Loans, a financial company that works with trucking and transport companies. “Implementing fuel-efficient practices and securing fuel contracts can provide some stability. Additionally, using data analytics to optimize routes can reduce fuel consumption.”
Commercial insurance premiums also have soared in recent years because of rising litigation costs and increased accident claims, further squeezing profit margins.
How Competition From Larger Carriers Impacts Smaller Companies
Highly variable freight rates – influenced by supply and demand dynamics – lead to inconsistent revenue streams. Smaller trucking companies, without the financial cushioning of larger firms, can find it difficult to weather economic storms.
“Smaller trucking companies often struggle to compete with larger carriers on pricing and service levels,” said Shawn Plummer, CEO and founder of The Annuity Expert. Plummer has helped numerous companies in the logistics sector navigate financial challenges to achieve sustainability. “Larger companies also often enjoy a lot more familiarity and are more easily recognized, making them the preferred service provider for many clients,” he said. “Niche specialization and exceptional customer service can help smaller companies differentiate themselves and capture market share.”
Regulatory Challenges Drive Financial Instability
The trucking industry is one of the most heavily regulated sectors. Recent years have brought a tightening of these regulations, creating a complex and costly environment for trucking companies. While the goal of these regulations is to improve safety, environmental sustainability, and labor conditions, they also present significant financial and operational challenges, particularly for smaller operators who lack the resources to adapt quickly.
One of the most impactful regulatory changes in recent years is the Electronic Logging Device (ELD) mandate. Introduced by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), the ELD guideline requires truck drivers to use electronic devices to log their hours of service (HOS). The primary goal is to make sure drivers follow HOS regulations to reduce driver fatigue and improve road safety.
However, the mandate has significantly increased compliance costs for trucking companies. The FMCSA estimates the average cost of an ELD at $419 per truck, which includes the cost of the devices plus monthly logbook services.
Other regulatory challenges include:
- Stricter emissions standards aimed at reducing the trucking industry’s environmental footprint. Compliance with these new rules requires a significant investment in newer, cleaner technologies.
- Labor regulations focused on improving working conditions for drivers including fair wages, limited excessive working hours, and paid time off.
“Failing to stay compliant with complex and ever-changing regulations often attracts penalties, potentially pushing businesses toward insolvency,” said Chris Estrada, CEO and founder of Nationwide United Auto Transport.
Identifying Hidden Costs That Contribute to Closures
Every business has hidden costs that can creep in and wreak havoc on its budget. Trucking companies are no different.
Operational inefficiencies include aging fleets, inadequate maintenance, poor route planning, and a lack of investment in modern technology that significantly impacts the profitability and sustainability of trucking companies.
Older trucks are one of the most visible signs of operational inefficiency in the trucking industry. As the trucks age, they become more prone to breakdowns and require more frequent and costly repairs. Decreased reliability and increased downtown equals lost revenue.
Cashflow’s Role in Hidden Costs
Many trucking companies struggle with cash flow, making it difficult to keep up with the industry’s operational demands.
“Delays in high operational costs can cause a crippling financial gap,” said Zhou. “Therefore, ensuring consistent cash flow through better payment terms and effective invoicing systems is crucial. Companies should also maintain a reserve fund to manage unexpected expenses.”
Technology Disruption’s Role in Truck Company Closures
Technological advancements such as telematics, autonomous vehicles, and digital freight platforms promise to revolutionize efficiency and reduce costs. However, transitioning to these new technologies is disruptive and costly for the trucking industry.
“Many companies lag in implementing advanced logistics and fleet management technologies, which can lead to inefficiencies,” said Plummer. “Investing in modern technology can streamline operations and improve profitability.”
The rise of autonomous trucks could be a double-edged sword. “On one hand, it can be an excellent way for struggling companies to reduce labor costs and increase efficiency in the long run,” Plummer said. “On the other hand, the high initial investment and potential job displacement could pose significant challenges.”
Facing the Reality of Truck Company Closures
The challenges truck companies face today are multifaceted and deeply intertwined. Economic pressures, regulatory overload, and technology disruption are just a few pressing issues that can drive truck company closures.
Identifying a sustainable path in the trucking industry is challenging but achievable with strategic planning, investment in technology and human resources, and a commitment to continuous improvement.
“Preventing these failures involves several initiatives, including keeping a close watch on expenditures, regularly updating business strategies, prioritizing compliance, efficient financial management, and embracing technology advancements,” said Estrada. “The journey is demanding, but a commitment to continual improvement can help companies thrive in this challenging landscape.”
View More